The Art of the First Course: Best Appetizers to Serve at Your Next Dinner Party

Small Bites, Grand Gestures: Appetizers That Steal the Show

By Critics Choice Catering and Event Production Inc

A dinner party is more than a meal — it’s theatre, memory-making, and just a little bit of magic. And the opening act? The appetizers. They’re the first impression your guests get, and the best ones strike that perfect balance of sophistication and fun.

At Critics Choice Catering & Events, we’ve mastered the art of the stylish starter. Here are a few of our favorites to set the tone at your next soirée.

1. The Raw Seafood Bar: A Crowd-Pleasing Classic

There’s something undeniably show-stopping about a raw bar glistening with oysters, shrimp, and crab claws. It’s not just food — it’s a spectacle. Fun fact: Critics Choice actually began in the 1970s as Scott’s Seafood Show, known for decadent raw bar displays that wowed partygoers long before Instagram. We’ve kept that spirit alive — because nothing says “celebration” quite like seafood on ice.

2. Mashed Potato Bar: Comfort in Couture

Mashed potatoes in a martini glass? Yes, please. With toppings like bacon, caramelized onions, and sharp cheddar, this station takes the world’s most comforting dish and dresses it up for a night out. Think of it as black tie… with gravy.

3. Bacon-Wrapped Dates with Edible Flowers: Tiny, but Mighty

Sweet dates, smoky bacon, and a hint of floral whimsy — these are the bites your guests will be sneaking seconds (and thirds) of. Proof that sometimes the smallest things make the biggest impression.

4. Mini Grilled Cheese with Tomato Soup Shooters: A Playful Pairing

It’s the grown-up version of your childhood favorite — golden, gooey grilled cheese paired with a silky sip of tomato soup. Nostalgic enough to make everyone smile, elevated enough to deserve a cocktail dress.

5. The Over-the-Top Cheese Board: Grazing, Elevated

Not just cheese and crackers — a true showpiece of artisan cheeses, charcuterie, fruits, nuts, and spreads. Styled like a masterpiece, this board isn’t just something to nibble on; it’s edible art your guests will gather around (and Instagram before tasting).

6. Pesto Lamb Chops: A Bite of Bold Luxury

Tender lamb chops brushed with vibrant pesto — bold, aromatic, and unapologetically indulgent. They’re hearty enough to anchor the menu, but bite-sized enough to keep the evening moving. Think of them as the little black dress of appetizers: timeless, daring, and unforgettable.

The Critics Choice Touch

From whimsical comforts to over-the-top indulgences, appetizers should spark delight before the first course is ever served. At Critics Choice Catering & Events, we’ve spent generations perfecting these opening acts — blending tradition with a dash of flair. Because the most memorable parties always begin with something small, something stylish, and something utterly delicious.

A Toast to Our Trusted Partners

At Critics Choice Catering & Events, unforgettable celebrations are a team effort. We’re grateful for the incredible vendors who help us bring every vision to life — from florists and rental companies to planners and photographers. Their talent and creativity make each event shine, and we’re proud to collaborate with the very best.

Vendors:

@chouraevents

@magicalblooms

@stephanieslinens